Mindful Conversations

Where Buddhism Meets Gendlin

The Honeyball Teaching (A Fictional Telling)

 

 

The Honeyball Teaching

A Narrative Retelling of the Madhupiṇḍika Sutta (MN 18)
by Christopher Ash (Formerly Christopher McLean)

1. The Encounter in the Great Wood

One time the Fortunate One was staying in Sakyan country, near his birthplace of Kapilavatthu, in the Banyan Park. In the early morning, he went to Kapilavatthu for his almsround and to eat his meal. Afterward he went to the Great Wood for the afternoon’s abiding. Going deep into the Great Wood, he sat down at the root of a young bilva tree.

Now, the Sakyan Daṇḍapāṇi (whose name means “Stick-in-hand”) was roaming about for exercise, leaning on his stick. So it was that he also came to the Great Wood, and going deep into the wood, he came upon that bilva tree where the Fortunate One sat. On arrival he exchanged friendly greetings with the Fortunate One. When the greetings were concluded, he stood to one side, resting on his stick, and asked:

“What is the recluse’s doctrine? What does he teach?”

The Fortunate One replied: “Friend, I teach a doctrine according to which one does not quarrel with anyone in the world with its devas, Māras, and Brahmās, in this generation with its recluses and brahmins, its princes and men. It is a teaching by which perceptions no longer beset a person who abides detached from sensual pleasures, without perplexity, freed from worry, devoid of craving for existence. That is my doctrine; that is what I teach.”

When this was said, Daṇḍapāṇi shook his head, wagged his tongue, and raised his eyebrows into three wrinkles on his forehead. Then, leaning on his stick, he departed.

2. The Brief Summary at Banyan Park

When the afternoon was over, the Fortunate One rose from his day’s abiding and went back to the Banyan Park. He sat down on the prepared seat and told the bhikkhus what had taken place between himself and Daṇḍapāṇi the Sakyan.

When he had told them, a bhikkhu asked: “Sir, what is this teaching by which one does not quarrel with anyone in the world? And how is it that perceptions no longer beset a person who abides detached from sensual pleasures?”

The Fortunate One answered: “Bhikkhu, as to the source through which perceptions and categories born of mental proliferation beset a person: if nothing is found there to delight in, welcome, and hold to, this is the end of the underlying tendency to lust, the end of the underlying tendency to aversion, the end of the underlying tendency to views, the end of the underlying tendency to doubt, the end of the underlying tendency to conceit, the end of the underlying tendency to desire for existence, the end of the underlying tendency to ignorance. This is the end of taking up rods and weapons, of quarrels, disputes, accusations, divisive talk, and false speech; here these evil unwholesome states cease without remainder.”

That is what the Fortunate One said. Having said this, the Well-Farer rose from his seat and went into his dwelling.

3. Approaching Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna

Soon after the Fortunate One had left, the bhikkhus thought: “The Fortunate One has just given a brief summary and gone into his dwelling without explaining its detailed meaning. Now who can explain the detailed meaning of this brief summary?”

Then they thought: “Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna is praised by the Teacher and esteemed by his wise companions in the holy life. He is capable of expounding the detailed meaning of this summary given in brief by the Fortunate One. Suppose we were to go to Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna and ask him about the meaning of this?”

So the bhikkhus went to Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna and exchanged greetings with him. When the friendly greetings were finished, they sat down to one side and told him what had taken place, asking: “Let Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna expound the meaning to us.”

Mahā-Kaccāna smiled and said: “Friends, it is as though a man needing heartwood, seeking heartwood, wandering in search of heartwood, thought that heartwood should be sought for among the branches and leaves of a great tree, after he had passed over the root and the trunk. And so it is with you, venerable sirs, that you think I should be asked about the meaning of this, after you passed the Fortunate One by when you were face to face with the Teacher. For knowing, the Blessed One knows; seeing, he sees; he is vision, he is knowledge, he is the Dhamma, he is the holy one; he is the sayer, the proclaimer, the elucidator of meaning, the giver of the Deathless, the lord of the Dhamma, the Tathāgata. That was the time when you should have asked the Fortunate One the meaning. As he told you, so you should have remembered it.”

“Surely, friend Kaccāna, knowing, the Blessed One knows; seeing, he sees… That was the time when we should have asked the Fortunate One. Yet Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna is praised by the Teacher and appreciated by his companions in the holy life. You are capable of analyzing the detailed meaning of this teaching given in brief. Please, walk us through the meaning, friend Kaccāna!”

“In that case, friends, listen carefully. We will see what we can learn from this teaching.”

4. The Unpacking of Proliferation (Papañca)

Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna said:

“Friends, when the Fortunate One gave that brief statement: ‘As to the source through which perceptions and categories born of mental proliferation beset a person: if nothing is found there to delight in, welcome, and hold to, this is the end of the underlying tendencies…’, I understand the detailed meaning to be as follows:

Dependent on the eye and visible forms, eye-consciousness arises. The meeting of the three is contact. With contact as condition, there are feeling-tones—pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral. What one feels, one perceives. What one perceives, one thinks about. What one thinks about, one mentally proliferates. What one mentally proliferates, with that as source, perceptions and categories born of mental proliferation beset a person with respect to past, future, and present forms cognizable by the eye.

Dependent on the ear and sounds, ear-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the nose and odors, nose-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the tongue and tastes, tongue-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the body and tactile objects, body-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the mind and mental phenomena, mind-consciousness arises…

So, brothers, where there is the eye, forms, and eye-consciousness, it is possible to delineate contact. Where contact is delineated, feeling-tone is delineated. Where feeling-tone is delineated, perception is delineated. Where perception is delineated, thinking is delineated. Where thinking is delineated, being beset by categories born of mental proliferation is delineated.

Conversely: where there is no eye, no forms, and no eye-consciousness, it is impossible to delineate contact. Where there is no contact, feeling-tone cannot be delineated. Where there is no feeling-tone, perception cannot be delineated. Where there is no perception, thinking cannot be delineated. Where there is no thinking, being beset by the complications of mental proliferation is impossible. And so it is for all the six sense channels.

All the conflict in the world has its origin in the misperception of how things are—the misperception that objects of the six sense channels exist as solid, independent entities on their own side. If nothing is found there to delight in, welcome, and hold to, the entire structure of proliferation collapses.

Now, if you wish, check this with the Fortunate One. However the Eye of the World answers, that is how you must remember it, so that you can test it in practice.”

5. The Sweetness of the Honeyball

The group was grateful to Mahā-Kaccāna for his clear, inspiring exposition. They thanked him and returned to the Fortunate One.

They found him, bowed, sat to one side, and reported how Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna had expounded the detailed meaning of the teaching-in-brief.

The Fortunate One heard them out and said: “Mahā-Kaccāna is wise, bhikkhus, a person of considerable discernment. If you had asked me about this, I would have explained it to you as he did. That is the meaning of this statement, and so you should remember it.”

Ānanda, who had been listening, said: “Sir, it is just as if a person who was stricken with hunger and weak with thirst were to come across a honeyball, wherever he tasted it he would experience its sweet, delectable flavor. So too, any able-minded bhikkhu, wherever he scrutinizes the meaning of this discourse with wisdom, will find satisfaction and confidence of mind. What shall we call this teaching?”

The Fortunate One replied: “Ānanda, you may remember this teaching as ‘The Honeyball Teaching.’”

Ānanda delighted in that suggestion, and so it has been.

 

Being Oneself Dear

Self-Love as Living Care in the Early Suttas

The early Buddhist suttas offer an approach to self-love. They treat it not as a fault to be hidden, not as an ego being inflated – as in everyday narcissism – but as a living fact of sentient experience. It’s a basis from which safety, ethics and spiritual growth can flourish. The fact of self-love is simple to articulate, yet it is subtle if you want to experience it healthily, and its reach is wide. To use a modern idiom, this approach is grounded in the fact that our bodies have an innate ‘optimising dynamic.’ If this is not suppressed or indulged, a human body feels its ‘life-forward implying.’

Self-love, in this view, does not primarily mean over-thinking well of oneself. As I said, that’s the everyday version of narcissism. But healthy self-love arises from, and refers back to, the felt sense each of us has that our own life matters to us, and that there is a natural imperative to take care of oneself and others. In holding ourselves dear, we are not making an error to be corrected, but touching something basic in being alive. And when this is understood rightly, self-love participates in – carries forward – our care for others.

The Pāli texts do not use a single term for what we now call “self-love.” They speak of holding oneself dear (attā piyo), of one who loves himself (attakāma), of one’s own welfare (attattha), of being self-protected (attarakkhita), and of the self as its own protector (attā hi attano nātho). These expressions don’t point to a fixed concept but they direct us to a range of ways of caring for one’s own heart-mind, the citta.

What follows draws these threads together. It is offered not as a doctrinal summary but as an invitation to sense how, in the Buddha’s orientation, self-love becomes a practice rather than a mere conceit.

Queen Mallikā on the Palace Terrace

The starting point is an intimate exchange between Queen Mallikā and King Pasenadi of Kosala, recorded in the Mallikā Sutta (SN 3.8) and also in the Udāna (Ud 5.1). Relaxing together on the upper terrace of the palace, the king asks his favourite queen whether there is anyone dearer to her than herself. Mallikā’s answer is straight-forward: “There is no one, great king, dearer to me than myself.” And she turns the question back to him. Pasenadi, after a moment, admits the same is true for him.

Soon afterward, the king brings this interchange to the Buddha (perhaps he was unsure of its wisdom) but the Buddha does not correct him. He instead confirms Mallikā’s insight and speaks a verse (a common practice at the time, it seems):

“Having traversed all quarters with the mind, one finds none anywhere dearer than oneself. Likewise, each person holds himself most dear; hence one who loves himself should not harm others.”

Notice the movement here. Mallikā’s answer could be heard as a confession of everyday narcissism, but the Buddha hears something else: an honest report of how life actually feels from within. And from her statement, he points to an ethic – a ground for caring for others.

Self-Love Is Not Vanity

In a popular moralistic view, love of self is suspect – something to be suppressed so that love of others may take its place. The suttas don’t support this opposition. For the Buddha, authentically holding oneself dear is not a moral failing but an existential baseline, the living ground of any sentient life. To deny it would be to attempt to establish the path on a dogma. The issue, here, is not whether we love ourselves, but how. The Buddha repeatedly leverages this deep psychological fact to establish ethics, mental protection and spiritual development. Self-love, rightly understood, is not a closed ego-bubble (alāya). It is the very place from which the heart opens.

Taking Oneself as the Measure

The first opening is ethical. Each being cherishes its own well-being, so recognising my own longing for happiness lets me feel the same longing in others. This is not an inference from premises so much as a bodily recognition: if I directly sense how my own life carries itself forward – wanting to live, flinching from pain, impacted by the selfishness of others, and so on – from this my body knows that others are like me. The foundation of this is that bodies are resonant with everything else, in a felt interdependence.

The Dhammapada gives this its classic form (Dhp 129–130): all tremble at the rod, all fear death, all hold life dear; taking oneself as the comparison (attānaṃ upamaṃ katvā), one should neither kill nor cause others to kill. The Buddha is reported in the Nālaka Sutta (Sn 3.11) as suggesting we should live this way: “’As I am, so are these. As are these, so am I.’ Drawing the likeness to yourself, neither kill nor incite others to kill.”

Here self-love becomes the measuring rod of non-harm (ahiṃsā). The more truly I feel my own life from within, the less possible it becomes to treat another life as a mere object. The practice of mindfulness with situational awareness bears this out.

Friend or Foe to Oneself

In the discourse just before Mallikā’s, the Piya Sutta (SN 3.4), King Pasenadi is puzzled. Observing the behaviour of those around him, he asks who really holds themselves dear, and who treats themselves as a foe? People acting in a selfish way which leads to their trouble aren’t caring for themselves.

He takes his answer to the Buddha, and the Buddha endorses it. Those who engage in misconduct of body, speech and mind may well say, “We love ourselves.” Yet they act toward themselves exactly as an enemy would act toward an enemy – planting the seeds of their own future suffering. (Isn’t this, nowadays, so evident from the daily news?) Those who live wholesomely in body, speech and mind may never say they love themselves, yet they are treating themselves as a dear friend treats a friend, thereby securing their present peace and their future welfare (attattha).

So true self-love is not a feeling one clings to for aggrandisement. It is measured by what one’s actions do to carry one’s own life forward harmoniously, evidenced by our heart-mind’s (citta’s) pliancy. Living this way, one can then find peace with one’s mind. Self-love, here, is less a sentiment than a way of carrying oneself forward spiritually.

Protection From Within

In the another discourse, the Attarakkhita Sutta (SN 3.5), Pasenadi notices that people habitually seek safety outwardly – in troops of elephants, cavalry, chariots, fortresses and wealth. (Nowadays, it’s SUVs and huge square houses that look like fortresses.) The Buddha confirms that such protection is fragile and incomplete. Real protection is internal: built from ethical conduct (sīla), restraint of the senses (indriya-saṃvara) and the cultivation of the mind (bhāvanā). One who is virtuous in ‘body, speech and mind’ is guarded, even with no army at all.

How can this work? I haven’t room to go into this in detail right here; however, suffice it to say that through self-care one realises a level of unified body-environment interaction which is not established on such distinctions as inner-outer, me-others, good-bad.  Says a Sufi poet, Rumi: “Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing/There is a field. I’ll meet you there.” Furthermore, this is not only a citadel to be experienced in this life but remains so in the dying process.

The general approach regarding self-care finds a memorable expression in the Sedaka Sutta (SN 47.19). Two acrobats prepare to perform on a bamboo pole. Before their balancing performance the boss proposes to the young female assistant, Medakathalika, “You look after me, and I’ll look after you.” She corrects him: “That won’t do, Sir. You look after yourself, and I’ll look after myself. This way, self-guarded and self-protected, we’ll perform our feats and come down safely.”

This is subsequently reported to the Buddha, who approves Medakathalika’s point and draws the lesson for mindfulness: protecting oneself, one protects others; protecting others, one protects oneself. These are not two separate projects that happen to coincide. Inner balance and care for others co-arise in one event. A practitioner steadied by satipaṭṭhāna does not neglect others, but watches out for their welfare. In fact, in the Metta Sutta kindness is itself a mindfulness practice.

The Citta is What We Care For

When the suttas speak of “self” (attā) in a positive, practical sense: “Self is the protector of self,” says Dhammapada (verse 160); “for what other protector could there be? With oneself well tamed, one gains a protector hard to find.” Here, the word attā is functionally close to citta (the heart-mind), the felt centre of one’s experiencing. To care for oneself is, above all, to care for this. In the opening chapter of the Aṅguttara Nikāya (AN 1, around suttas 31–40), the Buddha declares that he sees no other single thing which, unguarded, leads to such great harm as the citta (heart-mind) – and none which, guarded, leads to such great good.

Being One’s Own Authority

In the teaching on the three authorities (adhipateyya, AN 3.40), the Buddha speaks of taking oneself as one’s authority (attādhipateyya). This is possible with uncontrived, mindful experience, accompanied by situational awareness. One who lives thus acts from deep self-respect and moral conscience (hiri). True conscience isn’t in import from without. It’s not the superego’s version of things. It’s from a deeper place of non-comparison. The mindful person knows whether what one does is true or false – she feels the ‘fit’ with life from within.

This is self-love as integrity. It is not pride, but a refusal to betray one’s own knowing. A person who honours this ‘inner sense’ turns away from unwholesome action – not from fear of others, but because they will not dim their own awareness.

Where Mettā Begins

Many people today learn loving-kindness (mettā) as a sequence that begins with oneself: “May I be happy, may I be free from suffering, may I live in peace,” then moving outward to friends, neutral persons, difficult persons and finally all beings. This is good. Seen in the light of the suttas above, starting with having metta for oneself is not a selfish move. It is an emotional anchor. A genuine, unreserved experience of well-wishing toward one’s own life becomes a boundless clarity, which can then be extended outward without obstruction – not as a rule applied, but as a felt sense carried forward into ever-wider situations – above, below and all across.

(The ‘five persons’ sequence, beginning with oneself, comes from the commentator Buddhaghosa, writing many centuries after the Buddha.[i])

The Community That Cares for Itself

The Buddha extends this principle from the individual to the collective. In the Mahāparinibbāna Sutta (DN 16), King Ajātasattu plans to attack the Vajjian republic and sends his minister to ask the Buddha’s view. The Buddha replies indirectly, naming seven conditions for non-decline (aparihāniyā dhammā). He says that as long as the Vajjis meet often and in harmony, honour their established customs, respect their elders, protect their women, and maintain their shrines and support those who live the holy life, they can be expected to prosper, not decline.

Communal self-care, then, is the macrocosm of personal self-care. A people protects itself not through aggressive power but through inner harmony, ethical restraint and mutual respect. The Buddha immediately applies the same conditions to the monastic Saṅgha. Whether as a person or as a community, one secures one’s future welfare by guarding one’s inner integrity. After all, I say, a community is only as good as the quality of care shown by its individual members.

Implications for Practice

The suttas’ treatment of self-love offers a corrective in two directions. Against the culture of self-indulgence, it shows that much of what passes for loving oneself is, on examination, treating oneself as an enemy. On the other hand, against a certain kind of ‘spiritual’ superego-ish severity, it shows that the path does not ask us to deny that our own life is dear to us. It asks us to sense our value more fully and with greater clarity, and to let it change us. Remember that it was by nourishing the living organism (kāya) just enough to support deep concentration rather than torturing it, that the Buddha discovered the Middle Way and achieved liberation under the Bodhi tree. (Mahāsaccaka Sutta (MN 36)

In practice this means pausing and attending inwardly: how is my heart-mind right now? What would truly be for its welfare? Such questions are not answered by formula. They are answered by an attention that stays with one’s bodily life-forward implying, with what is felt, and lets the next wholesome step come from there.

Conclusion: Self-Love as Living Process

In the early suttas, self-love is not a fixed attitude but a living process – a way of caring for one’s own heart-mind that, followed honestly, opens into care for all beings. Buddhism is basically taking care of self and others. It begins in the plain truth Mallikā spoke on the palace terrace, and it moves outward through non-harm, inner protection, mindful attention, integrity, loving-kindness and communal harmony. Here, holding oneself dear is not the opposite of holding others dear. It is where the holding begins. Protecting oneself, one protects others; protecting others, one protects oneself.

oOo

I welcome any feedback: christopher at wholebodymindfulness dot com.


[i]The Buddha did not teach the now-common practice of beginning mettā with oneself and moving through a sequence of persons. That sequence comes from Buddhaghosa, in Chapter IX of the Visuddhimagga. In the suttas, the Buddha teaches mettā as a directional practice – pervading above, below, across and everywhere, the whole world (loka) of one’s experience. Buddhaghosa’s version, however, is not contrary to the spirit of the Buddha’s instructions. You can find online.

Letter to Kalyanamitta

An Open Letter on Purposelessness

13 Oct 2026

Dear Friends,

I want to write to you about something that comes up again and again in our practice, sometimes as a hope and sometimes as a fear: purposelessness. Buddhism calls it aimlessness or wishlessness (appaṇihita). In Chan and Zen it is called nonseeking (wuqiu). In Taoism it’s the effortlessness of wei-wu-wei. To the Christian mystic Meister Eckhart it was: ‘living without a why.’

Let me begin by clearing up a common misunderstanding, though. True purposelessness is not nihilistic collapse, apathy or depression. It’s a responsiveness, an open, engaged abiding here and now.

A.H. Almaas points out that mistaking spiritual ‘purposelessness’ for meaninglessness or haphazard passivity is an error. It is a state of disconnection, not realisation:
“One cannot say that there is no such thing as purpose and motivation, and that it is therefore fine to live a haphazard and meaningless life. That attitude would abrogate one’s human nature, for as long as one still lives in the cognitive sphere one’s life requires purpose and meaning… Only when we have integrated the nonconceptual can we say we do not need meaning, purpose, or motive. Otherwise, we will be stuck in the meaninglessness and purposelessness that are the opposite of meaning and purpose.” – Inner Journey Home

True purposelessness is not absence of vitality; it is what remains when egoic striving ceases. It’s grounded in a dimension that is deeper than perception or thought.

Put simply, it is the freedom that arrives when you stop treating the present moment as a stepping stone to somewhere else. Here are four practical insights which can help you meet this in daily life and in practice.

1. Practise what you do as an instance of now

In ordinary life, and often in spiritual life too, we fall into what Chögyam Trungpa named as ‘spiritual materialism’ – doing our spiritual practice get something. We meditate to become calm. We work on ourselves to become a “better” person. We do mindfulness to help us be a success. (I’ve heard that called ‘neoliberal spirituality’.) If you spot a version of that in yourself, don’t judge it. Being hard on yourself is more of the same. Simple let it go. Everything does move on. An Tibetan acquaintance once suggested the example of someone up on the stage in the movie theatre with his cans of paint, trying to capture the moving picture.

There’s a lovely story in the Devasamyutta about the Buddha meditating in the forest and a deva named Kakudha approaches him and says, “Are you happy?” The Buddha answers “On gaining what, Friend?” The deva reframes and says, “Are you unhappy?” The Buddha says, “What has been lost, Friend?” This is appaṇihita. (It also suggests that there are no things to gain or lose; it’s all change.) When you sit, you sit simply because you are already-always present – not to manufacture a special state. Of course, relax. Let go of stressing, just because gaining mind is stressful. Put the burden down.

Thich Nhat Hanh offers a apt image for this: “Does a rose have to do something? No, the purpose of a rose is to be a rose. Your purpose is to be yourself.” (The Heart of the Buddha’s Teachings) When you stop chasing an ideal self – indeed, chasing being any kind of self – striving comes to a peaceful halt, and you can rest in the sufficiency already present.

2. Disarm the watcher and drop the internal struggle

The ego, misconceiving itself, is forever trying to manage experience and secure feedback that it’s okay – that it’s in charge, real, and existent as an ultimate. It fights against what is. Much of our tiredness comes from this barely noticeable, but constant effort. Of course, you do notice it, but rarely notice as that kind of effort. You say it’s bad meditation, or some kind of problem. Drop the habitual commentary on how you’re getting it wrong.

Working with purposelessness means practising non-striving: letting the mind be open and uncalculated, without trying to subdue or control its energy. Krishnamurti and David Bohm (in The Ending of Time) observed that a mind freed from a fixed aim is not dull or dormant. It becomes more alive, because a larger intelligence can finally move without the ego getting in the way.

3. Need or want? Should or could?

A common fear is that without purpose we will become passive and stop caring. Yet, as both Christopher Gowans (Philosophy of the Buddha) and Sue Hamilton (I of the Beholder) note, the Buddha taught actively for some 45 years after his awakening. He acted constantly, but without binding cravings or selfish motive. We can drop investing hope for outcomes and just do what we do assured that the body-environment interaction carries us and our situations forward. The whole moves with this interactive body’s changes, which will signal the health of the move. Remember, in this context, to live without a ‘why’ is still living.

We could ask two simple questions to bring non-seeking into view:

What do I need, and what do I want? Needs keep body and community healthy. But, what you experience as a ‘need’ might be manufactured, too. Do I really need this (new device, or whatever)?
Wants can be healthy also, but they often tend to emerge from a sense of lack. ‘Want’ actually can mean ‘lack.’ So, we can ask, “What kind of lack is it?” How will we tell the difference between healthy and unhealthy wants and needs? A wanting might indicate your true need. If you want or feel you need something, check with your body’s sense of implying of its next step. Listen to the roots of your wanting, which are always situational. Situational awareness is an aspect of right mindfulness.

What should I do, and what could I do? Attend to what the situation in front of you actually asks for, rather than to endless projects that feed your self-image. Be careful of ‘should.’ Egoic functioning can be addicted to rules. “Should” might mean what other people say you need or want. On the other hand, “should” might mean “Ah! This is a good fit with the whole situation” – a real possibility. The bodily feel of the wanting without comparing it to, or defining it by, anything else is essential to discern the difference.

    [Note that if you do take time out to investigate your process, this too has to have a spirit of non-attainment. Focusing is best for this, because it requires an openness to what the body can tell you. (Focusing is yonisomanasikāra: attention in accordance with the ground.) This will ensure you don’t go off into unhelpful ruminations. Zig-zag between your questions and the fundamental space of experience-as-such.
    Also a quick note on ‘self-image.’ Firstly, because you are a flow of interaction, no image can get you. You aren’t your content, so be wary of self-image’s use. When you stop steering by your self-image and listen to what your body knows of the whole situation, you act well without forcing it. That’s what the tradition calls skilful means. (upāya).]

    4. Come home to the body

    Marion Milner at the beginning of the last century did a great exploration of purpose. “It struck me as odd that it had taken me so long to reach a feeling of sureness that there was something in me that would get on with the job of living without my continual tampering. I suppose I did not really reach it until I had discovered how to sink down beneath the level of chattering thoughts and simply feel what it meant to be alive.” – A Life of One’s Own

    When you set down your top-down agendas, you do not fall into chaos. You land in the living body. Eugene Gendlin’s Focusing work shows how this can unfold. When we stop forcing a situation to fit our plans, we can turn towards the murky, bodily felt sense of the whole of it. Hold that felt sense with spacious, non-judgemental attention, without demanding a result. Given room, the body’s own intelligence answers, offering fresh and unexpected steps that carry life forward. We can flow with what he calls ‘eveving’ – everything in everything (A Process Model).

    In short

    If I could leave you with just a few reminders, they would be these:

    • Cease treating your life as a project to be completed.
    • Act in the joy and necessity of the action itself, not for accumulation or future reward.
    • Rest in the moment as it is felt, trusting that when personal striving falls away, clarity and responsiveness are present of their own accord.
    • And, lastly: “Let the soft animal of your body love what it loves.” (from Wild Geese by Mary Oliver.
    • And…

    None of this needs to be achieved. It only needs to be noticed, again and again, with kindness.

    Warmly,
    Christopher

    October, 2026

    This Being Human

    The record of human beings’ care is dismal. It’s plain to see that there is an absence of care toward nature, including our own – a fact reflected in the ongoing debate regarding ‘human nature.’ Contrary to this, the understanding from which I live is that we are nature; and, as such, we are an activity of a larger interactional life process.

    Some say we make war on nature. If so, why? If humans say they love nature, how come we are destroying it? Why do we – individually and collectively – act destructively? Why is it that we live as though the beauty of being human is up for debate?

    These questions are easy enough to propose, but the situation is subtle in its dynamics. The situation doesn’t easily change. Nevertheless, we have to start somewhere. So, to begin simply: our care is thwarted by our psychological separation from the one, great life process. Our mental processes divide us off from the rest of life, as though the separation created by our cognitive habits is the ultimate dimension – that the division is absolute.

    This division shows itself in the most ordinary workings of our thought. Consider, for example, how we become attached to ideas which manifest in our social life as opinions. In general, people hold to opinions so strongly as to be aggressive toward those who differ. Our daily news is filled with the evidence that this goes nowhere creative or healthy. It doesn’t matter if a person is from an individualist culture or a collectivist one, their attachment to individuality as their ‘core’ is misplaced. It creates a false core and then we wonder why we are always off-kilter. (I’ll refer to this attachment to a false sense of ourselves as ‘everyday narcissism.’)

    Of course, in some respects we are individuals; but not in all. The problem is that we pay so little attention to the ways in which we are not individuals in the way that we think we are. To transform everyday narcissism, then, we need a new way to conduct the process of thinking itself, so that we can gain insight into the real situation and harmonize with life’s process. That’s my interest in these pages.

    To many of us it is obvious that we can’t go on this way and expect to survive as a species. Ignorance of our place in nature has led to ways of living which are destructive of the very matrices upon which we depend. This is widely accepted now among thoughtful people, but I still don’t see a wide interest in closely examining the nature of our ignorance – our ignore-ance. I’d like to go into this with those interested, so I’ve taken to writing.

    oOo

    I grew up blessed on the one hand, because I grew up with a wilderness at my back doorstep; but I grew up disadvantaged on the other, in that the humans around me were violent, and even cruel. I was physically assaulted at home, in the streets, and in my primary school – not just by bullies, but by those in charge, those in authority. By the time I reached seventeen and faced leaving high school, I saw little joy in the prospect of life with the adults. In particular, the Vietnam War – an unjust war with its roots in false views – was raging, and the ignorant Australian government had instituted conscription of twenty-year-olds as law. I was thus oppressively aware, before the completion of my first twenty years on planet earth, of a need for a wider solution than the usual escapes offered to me. (The most common of which was notably the consciousness-dulling substance called alcohol, which I started consuming early).

    However, at that transition point of late teens, I fortunately met a direct and simple message. One night at a public talk, I heard a man seated on the stage before me say, “A field of grass is green because each blade of grass is green” a comment which kindled hope in me.

    This point, which at the time indicated a possible ‘whither’ for me, is not the whole story, of course – but it nevertheless sowed the seed of an intention to transform my own personal functioning as a human. I saw that I too – I, an ordinary individual – could participate in society, living in a way which by its nature was the answer. I sensed that this way, in principle, would turn around our habit of living from destructive emotions.

    It was uplifting to think that there was a way in which I could contribute something useful to the chaotic world I was entering. I took this person to be saying: “Don’t leave the making of a peaceful world to others. And don’t go looking for yourself elsewhere. Take up the way of peace in society, you yourself in the here and now.” I could contribute to the whole, by ending the roots of destructiveness in myself. Who else could do that, really, but oneself?

    Now, decades later, I understand that, because experiencing is core to all humans, then this, too, is a way of ‘generating’ human nature. Each of us can contact, understand, and transform our experiencing. If there is a human nature, it’s that we have ‘experiencing.’ It’s this which needs our care and insight. Each of us can creatively contribute to humanity’s experiencing. We needn’t wait for the others to step up.

    Animality

    “Of animality, gentleness keeps the secret. A fundamental and paradoxical wildness, as foreign to any kind of taming as childhood. Not falling only under the human condition, it delineates its limits. So close to animality that it sometimes merges with it, gentleness is experienced to the point of making possible the hypothesis of an instinct that it would call its own. It would be the trait of a primal “gentleness drive” of protection, of compassion — even of goodness itself. An instinct closest to the being that would be devoted not only to self-preservation but also relationships. What the animal disarms in advance, even in its cruelty (outside the range of human barbarity), is our duplicity.”

    – Anne Dufourmantelle. Power of Gentleness. Fordham University Press.

    I support a model of living which can (in a sense) ‘rewild’ us; not in the sense of returning to the land, the commune, or whatever (I’ll leave that to your preferences); but, I mean this in the sense of demonstrating that we are of the biosphere, already of the wild, and that ‘mind’ is already-always part of that bigger order. We have strayed from our ancestral domain, and find ourselves living very much on the surface of life. Our pervasive individual and collective disharmony is because we are not in alignment with this primordial depth. The wild order has never left us, even though we have packaged it in our conceptual units – and have come to believe that the universe really is comprised of bits. We can reclaim reality.

    So, now I’d like to turn my attention toward the core issue of identity. How does a sense of self work, and how does language affect that? And how do we turn toward the ‘primordial ground’ of Being, and reclaim good mental and planetary health? And, then, most crucially, how can we understand ‘mind’ in such a way that we enter into that depth of living which we need? I want next to show the experiential basis of the notions of self and identity; and, to suggest how such notions, when seen without duplicity, don’t contradict the central Buddhist teaching of ‘not-self.’ This will lay a foundation for our further topics, such as selfishness (everyday narcissism), and human destructiveness.

    To explore these questions, I am placing ‘experiencing’ at the centre of the way forward – just as Eugene T. Gendlin did, and just as the Buddha did. I lean in this direction as a result of my own changes. When I was in my mid-twenties – lost, and frightened of going mad – one night, a line from Bob Dylan’s Ballad of a Thin Man reached me. Dylan sang: “You know something is happening, but you don’t know what it is. Do you, Mr. Jones?” At that moment the realisation dawned, with great relief, that I was experiencing – full stop. And that we are all experiencing, and experiencing just ‘This.’ While it didn’t radically change the fact that I was having trouble accepting the ultimate, what I could recognise was that my experiencing was actual, and that it was intrinsically of something bigger. I had the sense that I belonged to an open nonconceptual dimension which was more real than my concepts about it! There was, I felt, a way forward!

    It might seem like a small thing, but it carried me forward because, experiencing being actual, I had an ever-present ground where I could focus my learning of how to live; and beyond that, where I could continue my inquiry into the nature of ‘mind.’ I didn’t understand the whole matter, right there – true – but I knew that it was true that I was happening and I could start to learn from my own living. I didn’t have to find someone who knew more than me. Where I lived and in those times, meditation teachers were as scarce as hen’s teeth. Nevertheless, I had something I could trust – the fact that something is going on, and that my experiencing is of that. I saw that could learn “from, with, in” this very body, because it was itself of nature. I realised that the body was not a pattern, but an openness to more.

    It’s worth noting a principle here, which was explicated by a Chinese Chan master of the Tang dynasty, Dongshan Liangjie (hereafter simply referred to as Dongshan). On his waking up from the ego-bubble which entrances us all, he is reported to have said: “Just don’t seek from others, or you’ll be far estranged from self. I now go on alone; everywhere I meet it. It now is me; I now am not it. One must understand in this way to merge with suchness.” – Translated by Cleary, Book of Serenity.

    As confused as I was, that night, a first recognition of “It now is me; I now am not it” had occurred. While I’ll continue to reiterate that thinking divides the Undivided, even so, that’s not the whole story. To grasp our situation of animality in a healthy way depends on a just such a recognition as Dongshan’s.

    oOo

    Preparedness for the Transformation at the Root

    That day, concentrating to understand what Douglas Harding meant when he said, “I have no head,” my attention ‘looked back’ toward where I expected my seeing to be ‘coming from.’ As a result, my thinking ceased; because no such seer was to be found, and I was left with only the bare activity of seeing a luminous valley before me. Some such discovery – that I am not the kind of being that I imagine myself to be – was inevitable in the situation. What’s deeper than my constructions, that didn’t come into full view, however.

    Right there – if I was prepared for such an inversion of the usual way of seeing; if I could see with an unflinching heart – right there was the opportunity to have ‘just the seen.’ With such an unusual, unconstructed perception, a special case of awareness can be discovered – one not established on the subject-object dualism. One can live deeply, seeing deeply, with that ground.

    Later, I found the following words which worked well to describe this moment’s opportunity. The Buddha spoke these words to a yogi called Bāhiya: “Let there be, Bāhiya, in the seen, just the seen.” When I took my attention back to find the ‘I’ who was seeing, then for a moment, thought stopped – because there was in fact no locatable ‘me’ behind my eyes looking out. I have discovered from experience, over the years since that day, that in the state which the Buddha described to Bāhiya, this kind of seeing has no ‘from’ (and likewise no a ‘toward’). Space as we normally know it collapses.

    If you are ready for the shift, a dissolution of your unexamined sense of ‘I-dentity’ occurs; an ‘I-dentity’ which has hitherto, for as long as you can remember, functioned to concoct your seeing according to personal agendas. The popular way of speaking about this these days is in terms of ‘projections.’ We see ‘over there’ what we are ‘here’ – at our end of the imagined ‘from and to.’ We see what we are conditioned to see. If, after becoming aware of the projections, they don’t happen, then there is ‘in the experienced, just the experienced.’ If you are experiencing ‘seeing’ there is just the seen. If you are experiencing hearing, there is just the heard. And likewise for all that you sense and cognize, whether you call it ‘internal’ or ‘external.’

    Now that I look back to that occasion, I can understand that the possibility in the moment when thought stopped was to experience my unity with all of life. When one’s heart is sufficiently open, then naked seeing simple ceases to support the egoic sense of self, which really only sees its own self in the other. You may have had an intimation of this kind of experience if you have ever experienced an eye-to-eye encounter with an infant in its first month of life. Meeting the child’s simple, intimate, undefended gaze can be disconcerting to our habituated sense of self. The directness of the child’s gaze is such that you might feel uncomfortable at your end, unless you are in a special mode of consciousness – for example, if you have a parent’s presence, which is conditioned by millions of years of evolution. (Think ‘oxytocin,’ for instance.)

    If, on the other hand, when looking back at the child with naked awareness – that is, if you don’t have some egoic state at your end – you will experience the dissolution of your ordinary sense of self. In his words to Bāhiya, the Buddha described the cessation this way, “When, in the seen, there is just the seen, then you are ‘not by that.’” Your awareness will not be established on the basis of imagining or conceiving the other at all, and at that juncture your egoic sense of self has no basis to stand upon. You might feel naked.

    This egoic sense of self is what the Buddha spoke about soon after his awakening (recorded in a text called The Noble Search). There he is portrayed as saying that the truth which he had discovered was too profound for the unprepared to see – “hard to see and hard to understand, peaceful and sublime, unattainable by mere reasoning.” He felt that it was too subtle to teach to ‘this generation which delights in the sense of an ego-self. They delight in the sense of an ego-self, rejoice in the sense of an ego-self.”

    In this text, the Pāli word which I’ve translated here as ‘sense of an ego-self’ is ‘ālaya,’ which points to a ‘substrate.’ So, based on how it manifests at the substrate level, I’m tempted to translate it more evocatively as ‘the ego bubble.’ He’s saying, “People relish their ego-bubble. They love it and rejoice in it. It’s therefore hard for them to see this truth of dependent arising.”

    This is a helpful pointer to how we can think of our ‘preparedness’ for the revelation of a genuine ‘unestablished awareness,’ and the inversion of our usual world-view. Preparedness comes seamlessly when we compassionately study the ‘ego-bubble’ and become so familiar with it that we intimately know its drawbacks and dangers. We need to know ourselves. We need to comprehend our false sense of self so thoroughly that it loses its power over our experiencing. Then a deeper ground of living emerges.

    And this needs to be a ‘combodied’ approach – that is, an approach based in mindfulness in this very body, this lived body which co-arises with all. This is the path I took to heal from the errors of understanding which beset me over the next couple of years.

    Let’s notice now, then, that the real issue is not about ‘heads.’ The subject of the statement “I have no head” is ‘I.’ It is identity which is the heart of Douglas’ message. As for heads, I’ll demonstrate that we need not fixate on having or not having ‘a head’; and, I’ll do that without losing his essential point. My demonstration will involve understanding how thinking and saying function in relation to experiencing. This understanding was also an important part of my healing. This will mean a revision of the Harding method of speaking – a revision which we can look forward to. Nevertheless, we will stick to Douglas’ admonition to test all this in experience – to “look for yourself.”

    Today I leave you with promise that I will also unpack the Buddha’s enigmatic comment on this very topic, recorded in the text known as the Sutta Nipāta. A man called Bāvari consulted the Buddha about a hostile threat, made by a rogue.  This villainous man declared that Bāvari’s head would be split into many pieces through the power of black magic. The Buddha’s paradoxical response, uttered for Bāvari’s consolation, was that:

    ‘The head is ignorance. Understanding splits the head in pieces. It is destroyed by understanding, with its army of powers – that is, with confidence, mindfulness, meditation, determination and energy. These are the powers that split heads.’ (Sn1026)

    No Need for Struggle, or War

    What is this sickness called ‘war’? Isn’t it centuries of carnage on the basis of fabricated conflicts of interest, which are in turn concocted on the basis of an even deeper fabrication – that of ‘identity.’ The narrow vision of “Us versus them” is, in my understanding, a mental illness.

    Decades ago I was conducting workshops, and I offered an experiment in my groups in which the participants would be allocated an identity by me as the facilitator (playing God, if you will).  The premise of the experiment was that we don’t know what our identity is, in ordinary, everyday terms, unless others help us in forming and confirming it. All identity is formed interactively. The purpose of the exercise was to bring various sequences of behaviour forward which would illumine how identity is dependently formed and is dependently maintained.

    [It would take up unnecessary space to say, here, how I did this; but, briefly, it involved putting coloured dots on the participants forehead, where they couldn’t see the dot, while others could; and then giving appropriate instructions involving what methods they could and could not use to find out their identity. For example, no words or other obvious symbolic gestures. Originally, I myself participated in this exercise in a workshop with Douglas Edison Harding (1909-2007), in the early ninties. I then adapted it to my own varying purposes.]

    Our social identities are formed in interaction with others. The experiment was meant to convey a sense of real-life situations, obviously. For example, a baby is normally born without identifying with its skin group, its language group, or its native culture. Her/his/their enculturation is a fact which the baby can’t think about until much later – well after ‘identity’ has been set in train. Yet, immediately after birth (and even before), everyone around the baby begins ascribing a particular kind of identity on such bases; as I said, long before the baby has any self-consciousness of either of themselves as speakers of language, or of themselves as enculturated – long before we could think of our society’s methods of designating our existence and our inheritance. Waking up is in part waking up to how we’ve been formed by our culture. Beyond that, waking up is activating ways of relating that  connect us to a deeper ground than culture.

    Back to the workshops. There, I only offered the participants four different identities – one of four colours which corresponded to the four corners of  whatever room we were in. One unexpected insight we got at the time happened because on one occasion I contrived something that they wouldn’t expect. I arranged it that there were a few people in the workshop who couldn’t be identified by the others in the group. I gave them  a colour which didn’t match those of the corners. Their ‘no-identity’ status meant that they didn’t fit the pre-existing categories, which were symbolised by the coloured dots in the four corners of the room. Everyone else negotiated the experiment ‘successfully.’ Afterward, when everyone reported their experience of the experiment, those few differently-labelled people reported what it was like not to find their place in the available groups.

    They reported that it was disconcerting, even frightening, to not find a place for themselves in the whole group. In the course of everybody seeking where they ‘belonged,’ these people went through the attempt to belong in a pre-established group, and they found that they were rejected by each of the four groups. Even in such an artificial circumstance, this felt destabilizing. These non-fitting people found themselves gravitating to the centre of the room, and – here’s the message for the purpose of this essay – there they found each other. They gained solace from belonging to the group of non-acceptables in the centre of the room. The recognition that they had this in common with each other met an implicit need to belong – even in this artificial setup! They could belong there together, identified as those who didn’t belong to the bigger order.

    Let’s notice though, it was an identity which was still formed in relation to the whole group. Even the outsider depends on the normal people for their identity as an outsider. Look around us: the politicians of every political colour harp on about the faults of others because they are nobody without those others. I am asking, “How do you think you can you be yourself, by defining yourself in distinction to others?”

    In relation to the workshop participants (to whom I bow in recognition of their bravery), what is of special interest to me,  is that their fear arose on the basis of their thinking – not on the deeper basis of existing-as-Such. Is it really a big deal that I don’t fit in with pre-existing categories of thinking? Can I perhaps think freshly from my present situation, without moulding the situation to be a another version of the old order? If I recognise my existing-as-Such, isn’t there a place for me anywhere I am, even in death?

    In the workshop, at the end of the exercise, the people who were united in their ‘outsider status’ at the centre of the room, they still thought they absolutely needed a label which could operate in the pre-established order – the order which depends upon others’ mirroring your identity. They were trying to go on in the old way. Hence this specific kind of  ‘need for another’ guided them to feel a unity with the other non-fitting members, and to establish a ‘new’ social position. Identity, under these circumstances, is still not other than fabricated. I pointed out that this is what the disempowered in any of the world’s disadvantaged districts were doing.

    (Lest I be misquoted, I am not saying that the difficulties of the oppressed are their own fault. I’m talking only in the context of a much subtler and broader issue in the world, that of identity; but one which has devastating consequences just the same. Indeed, if our everyday, egoic identity didn’t keep society’s structures in place, would there be such a group as ‘the disempowered’? Wouldn’t the care for oneself and others which emerges from disidentifying with the false, wouldn’t that care ensure the ending of structures of oppression? Of course, it does. Care that’s not mired in loss and gain, acts intelligently.)

    If one doesn’t privilege this merely socially constructed mode of identity, enjoying others goes with the living fact that I and they exist-as-Such. It was said, “Immature love says: ‘I love you because I need you.’ (Fromm, 1956). IN my view, love-as-such says: ‘I love you because you are.'” It is in the mode of experiencing-as-such that we know we and the other are actual. It is not possible to maintain our fictions in this mode, so love with the actual do you become that harmful behaviour dies out, with our fictions.

    What was further interesting, as I conducted this experiment on a number of occasions, was how the non-fitting group could rouse antagonism (albeit mildly aggressive) toward the ‘normal’ people, toward the people who’s place was conventionally acknowledged. ‘Us versus Them’ seemed to arise out of a subtle resentment that ‘I am not  included among the normal.’ Furthermore, it felt empowering to be united as the ‘misfits.’

    All of this identification, of course, is a fabrication, whether the identity is ‘normal’ or ‘outsider.’ Its basis is in the mental act of comparing.

    Dear Reader, if right now you attune to dwelling in your situation – include above, below, all around, and in the middle, as your ‘situation’ – in its raw, living, unlabelled immediacy, is it comparable to anything, really? Aren’t all comparisons after the recognition, and hasn’t the recognition already changed it, moved it on to something else. When you start  looking for comparisons to that initial immediacy, then it’s changed.

    Experiencing as such is Such. By the capitalisation I mean to say it’s incomparable. It’s simply itself – livingly. (If you do get that, it’s good to then check your body for the magical feelings of innate warmth and aliveness, by the way.)

    Insecurity has its roots in false identity. Two beliefs or views which feed this insecurity can easily be named. They are at the root of most, if not all, wars. Firstly, to our cost, we identify with what is transient, what is contingently and rapidly changing; that is, we identify with what is insufficient by nature.

    So, being a changing being who is dealing with a changing world, I grasp at changing things to alleviate my existential anguish. Is that going to work? What could better define the madness at the root of war? Especially given that, secondly, when I’m identified in that way, I have an unconscious belief that I exist in the way I think my ‘self.’ Believing that this is so, I believe that I can be annihilated. In other words, ultimately we fear our identity will be negated and annihilated by any other who is different.

    This concocted mode of living is one which generates beings lost in thought. Such a way of life will never penetrate to the knowing at the heart of experiencing-as-Such. It can never satisfy us.

    Even so, it is powerful. It can lead us to destroy ourselves and the other species with whom we share this beautiful planet. Perhaps that is what the insane presidents and generals want, given their manifestly high level of dissociation from reality. These lost creatures. It is undoubtedly a miserably deficient way to live, to struggle so. I’m reminded of ‘I know the truth‘ by Marina Tsvetaeva. She knew another way:

    I know the truth — give up all other truths!
    No need for people anywhere on earth to struggle.
    Look — it is evening, look, it is nearly night:
    what do you speak of, poets, lovers, generals?

    The wind is level now, the earth is wet with dew,
    the storm of stars in the sky will turn to quiet.
    And soon all of us will sleep under the earth, we
    who never let each other sleep above it.

    – from Tsvetayeva: Selected Poems, by Marina Tsvetaeva.
    English translation by Elaine Feinstein. Original Language Russian.

    Harding and Having No Head

    “Sonorous thro’ the shaded air it sings.” (Pope, Odyss. viii. 214, ref OED)

    I thought I would be able to write about human transformation by simply giving a model of the human being that works. But my own deepest personal trauma kept presenting itself as I wrote. I was probably a little slow to realise that I’ve got to include it in the writing; but that’s where I’ve arrived.

    This approach immediately presents me with a dilemma. I want this writing to be as relevant as possible to a wide audience, but I am going to start with a highly unusual situation. I’m confident that this particular instance of human healing and awakening will have universal relevance; but, even so, it might initially seem to be far from my readers’ everyday life. I therefore hope dear Reader, that your kindness and patience will allow the unusual in this case – to put aside the thought that such a case is not likely to apply to you.

    I hope to demonstrate that such an ordinary behaviour as ‘seeing’ – the ordinary sense of sight, seeing per se, regardless of the nature of the seen – is a doorway to a healthy mind-process. Indeed, that any ordinary sense activity is a doorway into the transformative wonderment toward life which we humans so need.

    Close to fifty years ago I saw that I am not locatable anywhere perceptible. I am not found or located in what comes and goes; especially and least of all: behind my eyes. Another way of saying this is that after a very precise date, I could no longer ‘self-locate’ on the basis of the familiar inside/outside division. Wherever I looked, that distinction didn’t work to tell me who I am. However, for me this wasn’t as liberative as Harding must surely have intended it. I entered a profoundly ambiguous state tainted by childhood trauma.

    This fifty years of work have not been fruitless, however. I am more at ease with my unfindability than ever; and, indeed, I find it a blessed fact. The changes which I have experienced since then, though these changes may have been gradual, even very slow, can be understood, and that is my goal in this project. More than that, though, I am sure a theory of human change can be derived from this understanding – if only because I am a human like any other (at least in respect of those aspects which I will include in this account).

    Mine will be only one theory about human life, and I am not suggesting that it needs to be the only one; but, to be clear, I write it in the confidence that it is about being human, not simply about being an unusual individual who had an unusual experience. The basis of this confidence is that ‘experiencing’ is universal. As author Sue Hamilton-Blyth said (2000),

    “This is not to suggest that we all have the same experiences, but, rather, that what we have most in common is that we all do have experience – and, most fundamentally, the experience of being a human being on earth. Moreover, we all experience the notion of identity, of being human being A and not human being B.” (Hamilton-Blyth, Sue. Early Buddhism: A New Approach: The I of the Beholder.)

    I’m taking this to be a self-evident first principle for all that follows in my own project. While possibly not ultimately provable by logic, it has nevertheless the sonorous ring of sanity. So it is: that I start with a description of the occasion of this particular trauma.

    In 1975, I saw that I cannot be located. At first, my way of speaking about it owed its origin to the man Douglas Edison Harding and his little book On Having No Head. However, the matter was far from complete with that days’ events. Unrecognised by myself I was traumatised by the experience. The trauma in the situation was the shock of suddenly losing a fictitious sense of myself. I say ‘fictitious’ despite the fact that this kind of mental fiction was (and, is) shared by the majority of the general population of any country in the world – whether the culture is individualist or collectivist.

    As I alluded to above, the egoic fiction says that you can be identified with what comes and goes, what is perceptible. I was not prepared for such a revolutionary turnabout in my consciousness of myself. It was an inversion of the common everyday understanding of ‘self.’ This understanding could be essentialized as: Our self-representations present us with who we are.

    This break with convention occurred on a balcony of a home in North Canberra, Australia, on a fine winter morning, late June 1975. At this point in my life, I was not ready to so suddenly disidentify with the accumulation of self-representations I had built up since I was a small child. Hence, I experienced it as the loss of all that told me who I am. This project will be, then, in part, an examination of the meaning (that is, the experience) of the question, “Who am I?” – an inquiry into ‘Identity.’

    As a separate project, I am writing an autobiographical fiction to explore the human phenomenon of Identity. So, to give you a feel for the experiential aspect of what I am conceptually describing, I’ll adapt passages from that manuscript.

    It begins early to mid-winter in Eastern Australia, in the capital town Canberra, when breath forms clouds in the morning air, and frosty grass crunches and squeaks beneath one’s tread; when growth seems stilled for a time. It was Sunday morning of the last weekend of Australian June, 1975, around ten o’clock.

    We begin our tale with a seemingly innocuous invitation from my friend Matthew. I am lodging temporarily in my friend Matt’s rented house, and I have just risen from a sleeping bag.

    oOo

    I had woken up earlier that morning on the floor of the study in Matthew’s share-house in Nardoo Crescent. I entered that day, the second full day in his home, supported by a sense of new a beginning. Dwelling each night in a sleeping bag in the corner of someone’s study, on the floor, might not sound an auspicious beginning to anything; but not waking up in bed with my dissatisfied wife held, for me, the promise of the freedom I was seeking.

    In the kitchen, Matt handed me a thin paperback, saying: “This might prove interesting to you, Tige.”

    “Yes?” I respond. I took the book. “Thanks, Matt.”

    The cover was striking. It was a plain white cover; and in the front was a cut-out in the shape of a human head. I had never seen a book published with a hole in its cover. The first page was presented through the shape, and there revealed was the title of the book: On Having No Head. “Clever,” I thought, as I considered the design. I browsed its pages. The full title was On Having No Head: Zen and the Rediscovery of the Obvious. A book on my favourite topic. I had been immersing myself in D.T. Suzuki’s translation of the Lankavatara Sutra, and absorbing everything written by Suzuki. I was reading almost nothing else but books on Zen in those days, contemplating myself and the world in their light.

    It was a mild winter morning, so I made a cup of tea and took the book outside to sit in a plastic chair in the benign sun. Matthew went about his day. There was a balcony at the rear of Matthew’s place, which overlooked the peaceful plain of a suburban valley. The air was crisp. The sky, a luminous pale blue. I placed my tea on the table beside the plastic chair, then paused to look out over the valley spread before me. Here and there over the still valley, the household chimney were threading the air with low, horizontal smoke-streams. The slight haze didn’t obscure the hill on the other side of the valley. Standing for a moment, I took pleasure in the familiar form of Mt. Majura over there. Then I sat down, put my feet up on the balcony railing, and I began to read:

    “The best day of my life – my rebirthday, so to speak – was when I found I had no head. This is not a literary gambit, a witticism designed to arouse interest at any cost. I mean it in all seriousness: I have no head.”

    With that, Douglas Harding had had me transfixed. This ‘rebirthday’ idea was as compelling as any of the enigmatic Zen koans and mondos detailed in my three volumes of Suzuki’s Essays in Zen Buddhism. I too was looking for a rebirth. Without pause, I entered into Harding’s invitation, asking: “What can he mean?”

    Certain phrases in this book were like signposts to that meaning. They appeared to raise themselves above the crowd of Harding’s sentences: “…absorbed in the question ‘What am I?‘” he wrote. And these: “I stopped thinking“; “Past and future dropped away“; “…utterly free of me.”

    I looked up and out to the sleepy valley. Those sentences echoed for me. “Only the Now,” the voice of Harding said. I was excited. This was a wholly new kind of book on Zen, with a wholly unexpected line of inquiry.

    Right now, under the blue of a southern sky, where I was gathering my energies inwardly on Matthew’s balcony, a flock of a dozen pigeons were circling above me. I noted the birds. And at the same time, I noticed how easy it is to be distracted from making this reading an experiential task. “If this not going to be just an intellectual reading,” I thought, then I really have to concentrate on ‘reality reading.’ Hence, I now more deliberately zig-zagged between reading a little text and then referring to my own immediate experiencing. Only the Now. The meaning wasn’t in the words, but in the experience.

    The pigeons were now at about forty-five degrees. My sneakered feet on the railing, the book before me. I began to practice. I read a passage or two, and then took my eyes off the pages to look past my sneakers, out over the peaceful suburban valley, then up at the birds – all the while delving into the meaning of ‘I have no head.’

    I noted the morning sun shimmering off their wings as they wheeled about, and a line for a haiku emerged in my thoughts: “Light bright off wheeling wings…” I looked back at the circling flock again, and then I looked inward, directly back to where I sensed I was seeing them from – back to where my head most assuredly must be. At this point, no change in my habitual impression of ‘having a head’ occurred.

    I turned back to the little book. There on the page Harding continued his description of his awakening, which occurred when walking among the magnificent Himalayan mountains. He recorded that suddenly his thinking went quiet, and that when he looked, he saw: “…khaki trouserlegs terminating downwards in a pair of brown shoes, khaki sleeves terminating sideways in a pair of pink hands, and a khaki shirtfront terminating upwards in — absolutely nothing whatever! Certainly not in a head.”

    What could this man mean? I wanted to know.

    oOo

    Attention of and to the Matrix of Life

    When I think over the fifty-six years since I left high school, I can say confidently that I can think of no single thing which has contributed to my healthy development (in terms of growing up and waking up) more than wisely-directed attention. Conversely, if I think of the suffering which I have brought upon myself and others at one juncture or another in that time, inevitably the most influential factor in my harmful behaviour was unskilful attention. If you ask what characterizes unskilful attention, I would say that in general I have hurt myself and others when selfishness has guided attention.

    This may sound harsh, especially because when I left high school I was young – inexperienced, naive, and (in my case) very lost. That’s so. And yet, looking at the situation with an honest gaze, it was exactly that lack of self-knowledge that played a part in directing my attention unskilfully. I had much to learn, and the learning which has occurred was precisely due to the ‘right’ use of attention.

    What characterizes ‘right attention’? Development became possible when attention was directed to knowing myself as a concrete life. The etymology of ‘concrete’ is helpful here. The word descends from a Latin root which means: to grow together. In the present context, what are the processes which are connected, or ‘grow together’?

    I find this tricky to talk about, because the two processes I will start with aren’t ‘connected’ in the sense of there being ‘two processes’ at all. We talk that way, and it helps; but it’s not the most accurate way to conceive of our situation. That is, in a very real way the human individual is a growth movement with and of their matrix – which is the natural world. An individual is a separate process in some important respects, but not in all respects. World and organism are one interaction and move forward together. Your lived world and the big world of nature are indissolubly united in growing together. In his A Process Model Gendlin says that while the body and environment are in some respects different, “The body is a nonrepresentational concretion of (with) its environment.” That is, in its fundamental actuality it is one body-environment process.

    So, let me suggest that the world of personal experience is both ‘within’ and of the bigger world. This has been recognised for a long time. What the European phenomenologists called ‘the lived world’ the Buddha called ‘a world within a world.’ The important thing to note here is that one’s lived world and the bigger life process have always grown together.

    Humans have not only evolved ‘up from Eden,’ as has been said –  but, we have evolved with Eden. And the human process we call attention is still in the process of developing with vast nature as its matrix. When, at last, skilful attention led me to this realisation, and when I could confidently conceive of my body as of the world, then healthy development became organic.

    But where do we now find ourselves, at this point within the evolution of the wider world? Poised for extinction, or for a further development? At our present level of development, we can think of our attention as functioning on two different levels. One level is shaped by three major urges such as: the need to possess people and things (a going toward); the desire to be aggressive (a going against); and a limited ability to learn from the matrix of primordial experiencing (a going away).

    The other level involves disconnecting from the concrete in an even stronger way than simply a limit on learning. Via our capacity for symbol-making we effect a dissociation from bodily life. This second level creates the kinds of thinking and recreation of the world which are out of kilter with the way things are. This happens when preferences, thoughts, self-representations, and societal conditioning come into play. The matrix itself, of course, doesn’t prohibit this, but it is obvious that this level’s malfunctioning is not in favour of our continued life on planet earth.

    The arising of symbolizing in the species was not itself a problem. For a time this level carried human life forward. However, it is how we are using it at this stage in our development which has brought our present dangerous predicament.

    We will explore how this has happened, and the way forward. A large part of my project here is directed toward understanding what healthy attention is, and how it can develop from this ‘default mode.’ It might help us survive if we can develop attention in such a way that it can fulfil its true function as the world’s attention. It seems to me that this is an invitation that the bigger world offers.

    Inner Guidance

    “If one lets oneself sense the whole feel of now, a sense of direction emerges, if it is sought…. It is the whole of one’s living which shapes this direction.” (Philosopher Eugene T. Gendlin, Thinking Beyond Patterns: Body, Language and Situations.)

    There were so many explicit concepts in the previous post which would reasonably leave you with questions. I feel an internal pressure to return to any number of them. And, of course I will… in due course. However, so as to let felt thinking guide me, I want instead to pick up an issue which lurks between those lines. This is the issue of ‘inner guidance.’

    On what authority does one say something is true which is not obvious to the senses or to established thought? On what authority do you decide an external ‘authority’ is trustworthy regarding the tasks of inner transformation? And, if you’ve established to your satisfaction that they are trustworthy, how can you verify what they say for ourselves?

    To explore this in what follows, I think it necessary to contrast where we are going with where we are, or where we’ve been. In the ancient Buddhist texts, the Buddha deemed it necessary to contrast the ‘noble trained person’ with the ‘untrained person.’ I’ll generally speak of the ‘mindful person’ in contrast to the ‘unmindful person.’

    The unmindful person largely avoids ‘the big questions,’ and so misses opportunities to further their inner development. They don’t become the author of their own path, even when they are accomplished in philosophical talk.

    The point here is that one who wishes to have a reliable foundation for inner work must have a mindful relationship to evidence and authority. Being inattentive to our immediate, actual lives doesn’t work for that. Furthermore, even when mindful people engage the inquiry into ‘mind,’ they can bypass their emotional development. As I’ll explore later, the mere fact that a spiritual teacher has ‘woken up’ to the goal (however you name it) doesn’t mean that they’ve ‘grown up.’ That is, realisation of “true nature” doesn’t mean that they’ve dealt with their wounds sufficiently to guide others. A large number of spiritual teachers have harmed themselves and others for lack of understanding of this issue. But, let’s tackle this later.

    So, I’m asking: How can we be confident when we think we know something? Some say that we never can, but is this the case?

    We can say what doesn’t work to bring true confidence. When I was a young man, I shared with a friend that I was learning to be mindful. She asked me to tell her more; and upon hearing what was involved, she exclaimed “Oh, no! I wouldn’t want to know what I was thinking!” I was stunned. She was affirming a way of living which would ignore her mentality. (Here I want to set your mind at rest. There is a lot more to us than mere thinking. Mindfulness, in fact, reveals the breadth and depth of that ‘more.’ Possibly my friend intuited the vastness of the more, and baulked.)

    This ignoring strategy – a very weak happiness strategy – is more common than we think. Philosophy got a very bad name in the 20th century: even a pop song said that it was just ‘talk on the cereal box.’ When you set aside academic pretence, though, philosophy can be an on-going discipline. We can clarify our thinking to enhance how we live on planet Earth. It matters to do this. That’s why the Buddha placed a particular emphasis on getting your view ‘right.’

    Wonky thinking brings confusion in its wake. Unexamined thoughts influence action as much as, if not more than, the thoughts that are in your face, so to speak. Yet, in the matter of straightening out your thinking, the question of ‘authority’ becomes problematic. Belief doesn’t cut it. What then can guide our thinking such that our thinking serves us, and doesn’t control us? So that we can not be controlled, too, by others’ thinking. [?]

    “Throughout the world there is domination and tyranny – the tyranny of governments, the tyranny of churches in the name of God, in the name of love and peace. We have every form of authority thrust upon us, and most of us accept it because it is satisfying.” – Krishnamurti, Talk in Paris, May 20, 1965.

    Some people say that, in matters of spirituality, you need to accept some truths (passed on by others) provisionally, until you can verify them experientially. I’m examining this traditional assertion, fleshing it out. It has become merely a cultural dictate for many, a habit passed on over thousands of years. I haven’t got space here to say more, though I will when we look at the inescapable fact of culture in our flesh.

    We are better equipped for the task of independent learning than we tend to think. The scientific evidence is in: babies come into the world already gifted learners. They are inquiring minds. A newborn doesn’t suppose or believe anything, to begin the learning which carries their life forward.

    What might this mean for us? Even if that capacity has been dimmed by the harm created by our industry-serving education, we still have it. There are ways to uncover that flexibility. Unless we become beginners again, we will remain encrusted by culture – rather than empowered by it.

    If we already have an organism which is always in the process of carrying forward its development – an organism which generates itself freshly out of, in, and on from what it has just been – we only need to reignite the flame of attention that we were born with. There is a natural foundation present within us for the ‘getting’ of wisdom.

    Page 1 of 5

    Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén