The Honeyball Teaching
A Narrative Retelling of the Madhupiṇḍika Sutta (MN 18)
by Christopher Ash (Formerly Christopher McLean)
1. The Encounter in the Great Wood
One time the Fortunate One was staying in Sakyan country, near his birthplace of Kapilavatthu, in the Banyan Park. In the early morning, he went to Kapilavatthu for his almsround and to eat his meal. Afterward he went to the Great Wood for the afternoon’s abiding. Going deep into the Great Wood, he sat down at the root of a young bilva tree.
Now, the Sakyan Daṇḍapāṇi (whose name means “Stick-in-hand”) was roaming about for exercise, leaning on his stick. So it was that he also came to the Great Wood, and going deep into the wood, he came upon that bilva tree where the Fortunate One sat. On arrival he exchanged friendly greetings with the Fortunate One. When the greetings were concluded, he stood to one side, resting on his stick, and asked:
“What is the recluse’s doctrine? What does he teach?”
The Fortunate One replied: “Friend, I teach a doctrine according to which one does not quarrel with anyone in the world with its devas, Māras, and Brahmās, in this generation with its recluses and brahmins, its princes and men. It is a teaching by which perceptions no longer beset a person who abides detached from sensual pleasures, without perplexity, freed from worry, devoid of craving for existence. That is my doctrine; that is what I teach.”
When this was said, Daṇḍapāṇi shook his head, wagged his tongue, and raised his eyebrows into three wrinkles on his forehead. Then, leaning on his stick, he departed.
2. The Brief Summary at Banyan Park
When the afternoon was over, the Fortunate One rose from his day’s abiding and went back to the Banyan Park. He sat down on the prepared seat and told the bhikkhus what had taken place between himself and Daṇḍapāṇi the Sakyan.
When he had told them, a bhikkhu asked: “Sir, what is this teaching by which one does not quarrel with anyone in the world? And how is it that perceptions no longer beset a person who abides detached from sensual pleasures?”
The Fortunate One answered: “Bhikkhu, as to the source through which perceptions and categories born of mental proliferation beset a person: if nothing is found there to delight in, welcome, and hold to, this is the end of the underlying tendency to lust, the end of the underlying tendency to aversion, the end of the underlying tendency to views, the end of the underlying tendency to doubt, the end of the underlying tendency to conceit, the end of the underlying tendency to desire for existence, the end of the underlying tendency to ignorance. This is the end of taking up rods and weapons, of quarrels, disputes, accusations, divisive talk, and false speech; here these evil unwholesome states cease without remainder.”
That is what the Fortunate One said. Having said this, the Well-Farer rose from his seat and went into his dwelling.
3. Approaching Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna
Soon after the Fortunate One had left, the bhikkhus thought: “The Fortunate One has just given a brief summary and gone into his dwelling without explaining its detailed meaning. Now who can explain the detailed meaning of this brief summary?”
Then they thought: “Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna is praised by the Teacher and esteemed by his wise companions in the holy life. He is capable of expounding the detailed meaning of this summary given in brief by the Fortunate One. Suppose we were to go to Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna and ask him about the meaning of this?”
So the bhikkhus went to Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna and exchanged greetings with him. When the friendly greetings were finished, they sat down to one side and told him what had taken place, asking: “Let Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna expound the meaning to us.”
Mahā-Kaccāna smiled and said: “Friends, it is as though a man needing heartwood, seeking heartwood, wandering in search of heartwood, thought that heartwood should be sought for among the branches and leaves of a great tree, after he had passed over the root and the trunk. And so it is with you, venerable sirs, that you think I should be asked about the meaning of this, after you passed the Fortunate One by when you were face to face with the Teacher. For knowing, the Blessed One knows; seeing, he sees; he is vision, he is knowledge, he is the Dhamma, he is the holy one; he is the sayer, the proclaimer, the elucidator of meaning, the giver of the Deathless, the lord of the Dhamma, the Tathāgata. That was the time when you should have asked the Fortunate One the meaning. As he told you, so you should have remembered it.”
“Surely, friend Kaccāna, knowing, the Blessed One knows; seeing, he sees… That was the time when we should have asked the Fortunate One. Yet Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna is praised by the Teacher and appreciated by his companions in the holy life. You are capable of analyzing the detailed meaning of this teaching given in brief. Please, walk us through the meaning, friend Kaccāna!”
“In that case, friends, listen carefully. We will see what we can learn from this teaching.”
4. The Unpacking of Proliferation (Papañca)
Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna said:
“Friends, when the Fortunate One gave that brief statement: ‘As to the source through which perceptions and categories born of mental proliferation beset a person: if nothing is found there to delight in, welcome, and hold to, this is the end of the underlying tendencies…’, I understand the detailed meaning to be as follows:
Dependent on the eye and visible forms, eye-consciousness arises. The meeting of the three is contact. With contact as condition, there are feeling-tones—pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral. What one feels, one perceives. What one perceives, one thinks about. What one thinks about, one mentally proliferates. What one mentally proliferates, with that as source, perceptions and categories born of mental proliferation beset a person with respect to past, future, and present forms cognizable by the eye.
Dependent on the ear and sounds, ear-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the nose and odors, nose-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the tongue and tastes, tongue-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the body and tactile objects, body-consciousness arises…
Dependent on the mind and mental phenomena, mind-consciousness arises…
So, brothers, where there is the eye, forms, and eye-consciousness, it is possible to delineate contact. Where contact is delineated, feeling-tone is delineated. Where feeling-tone is delineated, perception is delineated. Where perception is delineated, thinking is delineated. Where thinking is delineated, being beset by categories born of mental proliferation is delineated.
Conversely: where there is no eye, no forms, and no eye-consciousness, it is impossible to delineate contact. Where there is no contact, feeling-tone cannot be delineated. Where there is no feeling-tone, perception cannot be delineated. Where there is no perception, thinking cannot be delineated. Where there is no thinking, being beset by the complications of mental proliferation is impossible. And so it is for all the six sense channels.
All the conflict in the world has its origin in the misperception of how things are—the misperception that objects of the six sense channels exist as solid, independent entities on their own side. If nothing is found there to delight in, welcome, and hold to, the entire structure of proliferation collapses.
Now, if you wish, check this with the Fortunate One. However the Eye of the World answers, that is how you must remember it, so that you can test it in practice.”
5. The Sweetness of the Honeyball
The group was grateful to Mahā-Kaccāna for his clear, inspiring exposition. They thanked him and returned to the Fortunate One.
They found him, bowed, sat to one side, and reported how Venerable Mahā-Kaccāna had expounded the detailed meaning of the teaching-in-brief.
The Fortunate One heard them out and said: “Mahā-Kaccāna is wise, bhikkhus, a person of considerable discernment. If you had asked me about this, I would have explained it to you as he did. That is the meaning of this statement, and so you should remember it.”
Ānanda, who had been listening, said: “Sir, it is just as if a person who was stricken with hunger and weak with thirst were to come across a honeyball, wherever he tasted it he would experience its sweet, delectable flavor. So too, any able-minded bhikkhu, wherever he scrutinizes the meaning of this discourse with wisdom, will find satisfaction and confidence of mind. What shall we call this teaching?”
The Fortunate One replied: “Ānanda, you may remember this teaching as ‘The Honeyball Teaching.’”
Ānanda delighted in that suggestion, and so it has been.